towhee [he/him]

  • 25 Posts
  • 288 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 7th, 2025

help-circle



  • towhee [he/him]toSlop.Oh no
    ·
    2 days ago

    I think this is a good post! People of color are often given the bill for accommodating white disabled people.








  • towhee [he/him]tovideosTime traveler from 2005
    ·
    7 days ago

    this is one funny thing that dates The Dark Knight, the joker goes on some long cynical rant the thesis of which is americans only care about going to the mall






  • towhee [he/him]toChapotraphouseWhy Jews are not a ruling class
    ·
    edit-2
    12 days ago

    If you don’t believe me then I can ping somebody for you, because, quite honestly, I would be very surprised if you were in regular contact with any Jews.

    I don’t personally believe the examples I gave. This is another reason the hypothetical-contradiction argument style is annoying, because you invite people to play in an imaginary world and then are horrified when they play in that imaginary world. We are talking about alternative explanations that a person you are making this argument to would find compelling. That being said, thank you for the in depth reply.


  • So the structure of your argument is argument by contradiction:

    1. Imagine a world where Jewish people are the ruling class
    2. In this imaginary world where Jewish people are the ruling class, education would feature their religious beliefs very prominently
    3. Education in this world does not feature Jewish religious beliefs very prominently, therefore by contradiction we do not live in the imaginary world where Jewish people are the ruling class

    My criticism is that the implication in step (2) is very weak. In this imaginary world there are many, many possible explanations for why education does not feature Jewish religious beliefs very prominently. It could be that the Jewish people who control the world are only ethnically Jewish and largely atheist, thus they care only whether their non-religious values are propagated. It could be that they view Jewish beliefs as hidden knowledge not fit to share with non-Jews. Fundamentally, arguing such a direct causality that you can derive a contradiction is hard to do in an alternate possible world.


  • Agree Jewish people are not a ruling class but this is poorly argued. In particular, the point about Judaism not being covered in education is easily explained by Judaism being an insular non-proselytizing religion, which in the antisemite’s conception is because they are a secretive society that keeps hidden world-shaping knowledge.



  • TNO is basically Half Life 3. It is an excellent and surprisingly tender-hearted game. The Old Blood is meh; it’s like meme Halloween DLC. The New Colossus is oddly different tonally from the first game in a way that is hard to describe, but just not as compelling for some reason.