Itโ€™s funny how the memory of a demonic teenage girl who feasts on human flesh can spark nostalgia. But thatโ€™s how it works with Amanda Seyfried and Adam Brody.

The stars of two of this seasonโ€™s buzziest shows โ€” the harrowing cop drama โ€œLong Bright Riverโ€ for Seyfried and the hit romantic comedy โ€œNobody Wants Thisโ€ for Brody โ€” met almost 20 years ago on the set of Karyn Kusamaโ€™s cult horror classic โ€œJenniferโ€™s Body.โ€ Seyfried played the nerdy and devout best friend of Jennifer, the aforementioned demon, played by Megan Fox, while Brody was cast as a douchey aspiring rock star who performs a satanic ritual meant to bring fame, and winds up creating a monster. 

Considered a flop at the time, the film found new life and cross-generational fans in subsequent years. It also provided the perfect occasion for a reunion for the actors, who have even more in common than โ€œJenniferโ€™s Body.โ€ Seyfried bought Brodyโ€™s Hollywood home, and the two also shared a bedroom in โ€œLovelace,โ€ the 2013 film about the trailblazing โ€™70s porn star Linda Lovelace. Here they reminisce about trying to get Harvey Weinsteinโ€™s attention for their early indies, parenting in show business and the overwhelming fame they gained as teens with โ€œMean Girlsโ€ and โ€œThe O.C.โ€ 

Amanda Seyfried: Did you play that video game โ€œGuitar Heroโ€ with us on [the set of โ€œJenniferโ€™s Bodyโ€]? 

Adam Brody: No. But I think you had a rental car, and we drove to a beach.

Seyfried: Yep. We got high.

Brody: I donโ€™t remember that. I was too high to remember that.

Seyfried: I donโ€™t know if I could do pot again. I think Iโ€™m allergic to it. I had some bad experiences. But I remember that being the most peaceful. That was probably the last time. I might have also gotten stoned with you at your house that I now own.

Brody: What a host.

Seyfried: You have an effect on people. Look at whatโ€™s happening: Youโ€™re in a hit show, and people are gasping, โ€œAdam Brody.โ€

Brody: I donโ€™t think itโ€™s pot-related. 

Seyfried: Itโ€™s just that you make people feel at ease. 

Brody: I really appreciate that. Iโ€™m pretty attuned to peopleโ€™s discomfort.

Seyfried: Everybody watched โ€œNobody Wants This.โ€ But with our shows, weโ€™re talking about opposites when it comes to genre and tone. 

Brody: Yours is sad and dreary. And youโ€™re in almost every frame. Was it a lot of heavy lifting? 

Seyfried: It was the first time I had been away from my kids five days a week. Our days were so long, Iโ€™d stay in the city and then Iโ€™d go home on the weekends. That was a lot of โ€œIโ€™m here for you, kids. If I end up taking a nap accidentally, you can cuddle with me.โ€

You were a producer on this as well. What did that mean? 

Brody: I was the kind of producer whose agent just negotiated a credit. But I did have the leadership role on set. I was No. 1 on the call sheet, which was nice because you set the tone. If youโ€™re a No. 2 or 3 and you have an asshole No. 1? The show can just be [awful]. 

I havenโ€™t been a lead on a series in a while, and I enjoy saying, โ€œOK, weโ€™re all going to be here for a minute. This is the family; letโ€™s get into a groove.โ€ 

Seyfried: My friend Katherine Pope, who works with Liz Meriwether and produced โ€œThe Dropout,โ€ sent me this beautiful book, โ€œLong Bright River.โ€ I thought, โ€œOK, Iโ€™m ready for this.โ€ The strike had just ended. 

What about you?

Brody: Kristen Bell and I are connected in a few ways. I heard through the grapevine she was doing this and was really recommending me for it. I knew I had a job at the other end of the strikes, and it did afford me some time do research. 

Seyfried: The show was originally called โ€œShiksa.โ€ 

Brody: It was. 

Seyfried: Thatโ€™s a genius title. We need romance. 

Brody: Thatโ€™s something that I love doing. It doesnโ€™t come your way that often, and if it does, itโ€™s not good. They make [fewer romances] now. Romance and comedy are a pure dopamine hit and were sorely needed in 2024. Theyโ€™re going to be sorely needed in โ€™25. 

In terms of the interfaith relationship, I think itโ€™s been relatable. So many people have come up to me and said, โ€œMy wife is a shiksa.โ€ Weโ€™re a great stand-in for any differences between two people, philosophical or cultural. When you merge two individuals, growth and compromise is what you have to navigate. 

Seyfried: And itโ€™s about what your families want. Itโ€™s โ€œRomeo and Juliet.โ€ 

Brody: On โ€œLong Bright River,โ€ the kid who plays your son is so good. Weโ€™re parents of similar-age kids, and I havenโ€™t portrayed a parent yet. Had you done that before?

Seyfried: As soon as the people of Hollywood understood that I popped something out of my body, theyโ€™re like, โ€œYouโ€™re a mom now.โ€ And it comes with a lot of benefits. The roles are richer. Are you more collaborative now that youโ€™re in the second season of โ€œNobody Wants Thisโ€? Are you bringing your own ideas? 

Peggy Sirota for Variety

Brody: Itโ€™s a very collaborative set, but I would say the first season was so in flux that we were finding the show together. Now we know what weโ€™re doing, so the die is cast and thereโ€™s a little less to discuss.

Seyfried: Remember when you played an iconic teenage character on โ€œThe O.C.โ€?

Brody: In my 20s. You were younger when you did โ€œMean Girls,โ€ right? 

Seyfried: I was 17, the perfect age for that. Except my mom had to live with me.

Brody: I was that Steve Buscemi meme of the old man saying, โ€œHello, fellow kids.โ€

Seyfried: You werenโ€™t that old. Are you kidding? The people from โ€œ90210โ€ were in their 30s. 

Brody: Have you rewatched โ€œMean Girlsโ€?

Seyfried: No. Itโ€™s on often enough though. I love it. I really love seeing my face on peopleโ€™s T-shirts. Iโ€™m a little resentful because Paramount still owes me some money for the likeness. Every store sells โ€œMean Girlsโ€ T-shirts with our faces. Donโ€™t I [get something from that]? Even the girl at TSA tells me itโ€™s her favorite movie. Oh my God, remember when we did โ€œLovelace,โ€ and I gave you a blow job?

Brody: An iconic blow job. The deep throat โ€” the titular deep throat. How do you feel about that movie now?

Seyfried: I had a great experience. It was a move towards attracting a level of respect for skill as opposed to โ€ฆ I didnโ€™t care about the reception as much as just changing the idea people had of me in the business. Itโ€™s just so easy to get pigeonholed. 

Brody: I remember Harvey Weinstein bought it. 

Seyfried: I had heard a few rumors about him, but not to the extent that it became. I invited him to the screening [at Sundance]. He showed up and said, โ€œI bought it,โ€ and I gave him the biggest hug. The whole room was buzzing. He was the big papa of the room โ€” we all needed him to want our project if it was an indie, because that meant it was going to go somewhere.

So 2003 was the year I graduated and did โ€œMean Girls,โ€ and the year you started โ€œThe O.C.โ€ We both had these pivotal career moments, and you became a pop star overnight. I canโ€™t imagine that was easy.

Brody: It was. We were in a bubble. It was pre-social media. I canโ€™t imagine it now. Now it seems like an incredible responsibility, where you could fuck your whole life up in one second. Iโ€™m really impressed with some of these kids who have this awesome responsibility of huge platforms, and some of them are brave and do whatโ€™s right.

Seyfried: I think doing whatโ€™s right is just hiding in a bunker. 

Weโ€™re making another [โ€œJenniferโ€™s Bodyโ€]. Are you going to do it? 

Brody: I heard. I wasnโ€™t contacted. I died [in the first one]. 

Seyfried: So did Megan Fox, and Iโ€™m not doing it without her.


Production: BAUIE+RAD; Production Design: Francisco Vargas