Log in | Sign up

  • 12 Posts
  • 3.16K Comments
Joined 2 年前
cake
Cake day: 2024年1月22日

help-circle




  • Thank you for being polite and not calling me a bot or whatever else

    You’re very welcome, but when I read this comment, I had a rueful chuckle because I worry that I’d been rather too argumentative to count as in any way polite, so sorry about that, and I’ll try harder to live up to your charitable interpretation rather than destroy it.

    I’m not convinced that it’s better in any significant way to have invented your own horrific policy slogan (that mirrors real nazi actions) than to have used a literal translation of a prewritten nazi one, but I decided before logging on that I was going to stop arguing with you on that point, so I should already have shut up and dropped it. Here’s the parting compromise: you’re right, it’s not a literal nazi slogan, it’s a newer maga slogan that just looks a lot like past nazi actions.

    So far the administration behaves in ways that are like the Nazis, but they do not openly fly swastika flags, etc.

    Many of their followers now do. I don’t really understand why explicitly and openly nazi is such an important distinction for you.



  • but not actually yet acting on it.

    I hope you’re right and I’m wrong, but deporting people for not being white is already happening, extrajudicial execution is already happening, disregulated millitias with no accountability is already happening, retaliation on the scale of cities and States for not supporting the leader is already happening, armed removal of foreign leaders for nakedly political reasons is already happening, threatening to invade neighbouring countries is already happening, and here you are telling me it’s all fine because at least they haven’t copied the Nazis by killing off a whole village yet, they’ve just written their message of annihilation on a podium?

    You are absolutely splitting hairs while citizens are openly abducted and killed in the streets. Again, have some sense of perspective! For you it hinges on the wording?!?!?







  • Pretending other people are dumb when your “joke” landed badly because it matches Republican taking points circa 2024 isn’t convincing me that you have a sense of humour. You sound like you genuinely believe you’re the only one in the world who ever noticed that the nazis misdescribed themselves as socialist.

    If you didn’t spend part of 2024 explaining to maga followers that nazis weren’t socialist, you can be forgiven for not realising in advance that those of us who did found your “joke” neither original nor funny. You claim to understand Poe’s law but are falling miserably to recognise its relevance to you.



  • I think that literally everyone who you ranted at are aware what nazi stood for, and that it is youth who lack awareness for not knowing that “nazi=socialist” was a right wing talking point, with exactly the reasoning you so angrily and repeatedly gave.

    If you knew what poe’s law was, why did you get so cross and defensive when I said you sounded like a right winger. If you knew that nazis aren’t socialist, why did you get so cross and defensive mansplaining that socialist is in the title? If you were making a lighthearted joke, why are you so cross and defensive when people didn’t see the humour? At every stage you’re cross and defensive.

    You claim to be joking, and claiming had people are dumb and poorly read for explaining that nazis aren’t socialist, but the more you rant about not having read a history book, the more you seem to have missed the point that nazis really aren’t socialist, when you repeatedly and angrily say “It’s IN the nAme, StUpiD”



  • I don’t think you read what Poe’s law says.

    You sounded like a right winger in the sense that you said the same things right wingers said, not in the sense that I believe you are one.

    And you talk to me about nuance?

    No, I don’t believe I did.

    you didn’t get the joke and are blaming me for it.

    I think that in these terrible times, if your edgy humour that uses the same logic as right wing talking points from 2024 doesn’t land, ranting at people for two comments that they don’t understand that nazi means socialist without making it clear that you know that that was intentionally misleading, instead of making it clearer that it was a joke doesn’t make you come across as a fun person, and is why people started explaining the difference to you.

    For at least five hours after your first post (which I see you have now edited), you just disagreed angrily with people pointing out that nazis and socialists are different. Why would anyone believe this was an attempt at humour?

    If you actually want to make people laugh, you need to lighten up a bit and be less defensive if it doesn’t land. It’s not my fault that your humour wasn’t funny enough for people to get it, so maybe blame the audience less and make it clearer that you’re attempting to satirise stupid magas rather than being one.

    There is no “of course that’s wrong and stupid, no one in their right mind would believe such a thing, so it’s obviously a joke” with maga folk. Hence Poe’s law.