We live in a society that documents everything online, from our opinions on current events to the first steps our children take. We can see what celebrities and friends we follow think, and it’s easier than ever to know what the POTUS believes. It has brought to light injustices that many have failed to see before, and it has stirred people to action and change.
However, social media is a double-edged sword. It can seem that if I fail to document my actions, few will believe I ever did them. Posting “receipts” of charitable acts can resolve this, or they can lead to people thinking I’ve only done something to make myself look better. Past mistakes, even ones I’ve apologized for and sought to rectify, may be held against me and can lead to being “canceled” as some celebrities (and even regular people) have.
Yet none of this compares to the vices that social media has allowed us to indulge in, laziness and ambiguity.
Let me give an example. When people use #defundthepolice, I’ve noticed a variety of reactions. One is the user believes funds going toward police departments need to be reevaluated and redistributed to other budgets or other aspects of police work. The other states that the person who used that hashtag believes ACAB (All Cops Are B*stards) and wants to get rid of law enforcement altogether. Chances are, it could be one or the other, or even something else, but determining which one requires actual research and an understanding of the term’s context. Our scrolls through Facebook over our lunch breaks don’t afford us the time to look into the meaning behind hashtags, and this can lead to a snap judgment based on our own beliefs to move on. Or, if we’ve muted everyone who doesn’t agree with our opinion, we never see hashtags like this used by anyone we know, and we become “outraged” when we see them.
I’m someone who loves learning, and I try to research both sides of an issue before I take a stance on it (though I would be the first to admit that I have failed many times in this regard). Generally, when I post things on social media, I try to explain why and whether or not I agree with it (albeit sometimes imperfectly). Recently, I’ve made posts that have referenced racism and stances that are similar to the Black Lives Matter organization. While I do not support the organization BLM (after doing extensive research on it), I have no issue with #blacklivesmatter. Researching the hashtag (and I did a lot of research back in 2016-2017 that I’m willing to share) led me to the conclusion that it primarily refers to highlighting the lives of black people as valuable in a society that in many ways does not value them. In other words, black lives matter too.
However, I made the mistake of believing others would do the work of researching as well or at least asking me directly to clarify my perspective. As I noted before, I do not support the organization BLM, but many who see #blacklivesmatter see it as support for the organization. So when I added #blacklivesmatter to my profile picture, I did so with my convictions surrounding it in mind. This action led to a few well-meaning folks from back home (rural Wisconsin) asking my parents about me because they were “concerned” I was becoming a “radical Marxist.”
I don’t blame my parents for asking me after hearing this. They don’t have social media. If someone told me they thought my child was holding views that were “insert radical or Neo-whatever terminology here,” I would ask for clarification too. However, my frustration is that this leaves me with the assumption that these “concerned” individuals did not feel comfortable talking to me about what was bothering them. Their discomfort makes me second guess whether or not I’m clearly explaining things. It makes me wonder what I’m doing that made these family friends from my childhood believe I wouldn’t listen to their questions. It makes me wonder who else feels that way.
It’s not that I’m afraid of disagreement (I have plenty of friends and family who disagree with me on a variety of issues), it’s that I will automatically be labeled something I’m not with no chance to explain. There’s a mutual responsibility to post with clarity and to react with openness to see where someone is coming from before deciding it. I’ve tried to do so in my interactions on social media, but it’s exhausting when it appears that few are affording me the same courtesy. I’ve especially realized this recently.
To conclude, I will be deactivating most of my social media accounts for the time being, and depending on how things go, I may never reactivate them. Learning and discussion can take place outside of social media, so it is time for me to log off for now.