In John Hawthorne & David Manley,
The reference book. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 93-154 (
2012)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
Chapters 6–6 look at various noun phrases in natural language, asking whether there is an interesting referential/non-referential distinction among them. This investigation begins in 4 with the phenomenon of specificity for indefinites. (‘Functional’ uses of indefinites and apparent exceptional scope are also discussed.) The chapter explores three views of specific indefinites. On the first view they are paradigmatically referential expressions. On the second, specificity is simply a pragmatic matter and does not affect truth-conditions. Both of these views are rejected in favor of a view (due to Roger Schwarzschild) on which specific uses of indefinites involve a special class of domain-restricting elements. In some cases, these ‘specific restrictors’ cause indefinites to exhibit some of the characteristics of referential terms. The chapter concludes by applying the view to various cases including specific indefinites in attitude reports, intensional anaphora, and the ‘non-specific de re’.