Under the scanner, yet generic cough syrups hit shelves

Synopsis
Worry is spreading regarding the multitude of cough syrup brands circulating in India, with alarming revelations of toxic diethylene glycol detected in some, resulting in heartbreaking instances of child mortality. This situation sheds light on the questionable efficacy of regulatory measures, as many small-scale producers evade scrutiny.
Difficult to Capture Data
PharmaTrac, a leading prescription audit firm, has coverage on sales of about 1,150 cough syrup brands in India, but sector experts believe the market is extremely fragmented and the actual count could be twice as much. Cough and cold syrups, popular fever drugs, or pain and inflammation medicines are among the most aggressively marketed to doctors by small and regional pharma companies.
"Incentives by smaller and regional companies sway the decisions of the doctors (to prescribe) more than the reputation of brands," said a senior area manager in a Mumbai-based pharma company. "In addition, in small towns, less than 100 kms from Mumbai, a shop chemist can recommend a brand of a drug to the customer."
Retail-level data and trends for such small companies is not captured by audit firms like PharmaTrac as they are either insignificant in size or operate in regions beyond these firms' coverage area. Sresan's Coldrif does not figure in the sales audits of PharmaTrac.
Though data for small pharma units is unavailable, sales of cough and cold syrups in India have risen 30% to ₹3,423 crore from ₹2,627 crore over the last five years outpacing the average pharma industry growth rate of 8-10%, showed data from PharmaTrac.
While unethical trade practices are a major factor, sales of cough and cold syrups are also being fuelled by rapid urbanisation, air pollution, and frequent weather changes triggering dust allergies and respiratory distress across age groups though it is more pronounced in children. Besides, irrational fixed dose combinations are being pumped into the market by small companies despite a sweeping crackdown a few years ago, and a ban on hundreds of cough syrup brands.
Regional Disparity
Inefficient oversight of state Food and Drug Administrators (FDAs) have helped unscrupulous companies to swamp the market with irrational combinations. In 2023, out of 14 irrational drugs banned for sale by the central drug administration, 13 were combinations for the treatment of cough, cold, asthma, and respiratory infections. These included amoxycillin + bromhexine + dextromethorphan, chlorpheniramine maleate + codeine and dextromethorphan + chlorpheniramine + guaifenesin + ammonium chloride.
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel)